A triptych of Tina next to Moulin Rouge and Jagged Little Pill

And the Tony will go to ... one of these three Best New Musicals: Tina, Moulin Rouge!, or Jagged Little Pill.

Photo: Manuel Harlan; Matthew Murphy; Matthew Murphy

The Tony Awards air live on Paramount+ on Sunday, Sept. 26!

By Nate Millado

Broadway's back—and our anonymous Tony Award voter couldn't be happier about The Great White Way's glorious return. "I went to [new play] Pass Over a couple of weeks ago and everyone broke out into mad applause during the pre-show cellphone announcement!" they said. With the Tonys returning to Paramount+ on Sept. 26—and a special presentation, The Tony Awards Present Broadway's Back, airing immediately after on CBS—Watch tapped this decades-long Tony voter to get their hot takes on theater's most prestigious award. Find out who they voted for (and why), then tune in to the Tonys at 7 p.m. ET/4 p.m. PT on Paramount+.

Read moreShow less