Aasif Mandvi wears a brown plaid shirt and stands between Mike Colter in a blue sweater and Katja Herbers in black while all three stare ahead fearfully

Mike Colter as David Acosta, Aasif Mandvi as Ben Shakir, and Katja Herbers as Kristen Bouchard

Photo Credit: Elizabeth Fisher/Paramount+

Revisit Evil’s most terrifying moments and watch new episodes of the celebrated drama, streaming now on Paramount+!

By Sarah Deming

A Catholic priest, an atheist shrink, and a Muslim contractor walk into a Brooklyn bar. No, it’s not a joke; it’s our favorite team of paranormal investigators, celebrating their newly green-lit fourth season!

A brilliant genre mash-up of supernatural and procedural, Evil is the brainchild of Robert and Michelle King, the team behind The Good Wife and The Good Fight. The series follows newly-ordained—and extremely handsome—priest David Acosta (Mike Colter), skeptical psychologist Kristen Bouchard (Katja Herbers), and science whiz Ben Shakir (Aasif Mandvi) as they assess potential supernatural activity. Is your teenager possessed by Satan or is it just a bad asthma attack? Are New York bagels literally a miracle? David and his gang will get you answers.

Midway into its third season, Evil continues to delight and terrify while also exploring complex issues of race, gender, and faith. Now a full-fledged priest, David is recruited by a secret Vatican society called “the entity.” Kristen struggles to protect her four children from nemesis Leland Townsend, wonderfully played by Emmy-winner Michael Emerson (The Practice, Lost). Ben feels overwhelmed and gets help from his sister’s secret science club.

To celebrate the gang’s return for a fourth season, we binged Evil and picked out its 13 creepiest creations. Apologies to anyone with triskaidekaphobia.

Catch up on all episodes of Evilstreaming on Paramount+.

SUBSCRIBE NOW: Enjoy 4 Digital Plus 2 Print/Digital Issues Of Watch Per Year — For Free!

The Ghost in the Machine (S1, E4)

Two of Kristen\u2019s daughters wear VR headsets and reach their hands out as if spellbound while the other two look on from the background

Virtual nightmare: Lexis (Maddy Crocco), Laura (Dalya Knapp), Lila (Skylar Gray), and Lynn (Brooklyn Shuck) get a gift from their grandmother that goes horribly wrong.

Photo: Jeff Neumann/CBS ©2019 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Evil understands the terror of parenting in the Internet age. When Kristen’s mother gives her four granddaughters VR goggles, a stranger from the Internet joins their game. Rose390 looks like a twin from The Shining crossed with the dead girl from The Ring. She makes the girls play with an Ouija board that says their father is in heaven: “You’re going to love being orphans!”

The Burned Girl (S1, E5)

A stranger in a plastic princess mask surrounded by Kristen\u2019s daughters in Halloween costumes as they shine flashlights into a hole

A mysterious, masked stranger peers into a hole along with Kristen’s daughters on Halloween.

Photo: Elizabeth Fisher/CBS ©2019 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved

For Halloween, the Bouchard girls host a new neighbor, Brenda, who arrives in a mask she refuses to remove. Brenda tells a ghost story about a horribly burned girl, speculates about matricide, and dares everyone to lie in graves. The worst part? Brenda’s mom calls to apologize for her daughter’s absence. So, if that’s not Brenda, who is it?

The Serial Killer’s Secret (S1, E7)

Katja Herbers wearing a black shawl over a white turtleneck stands next to Mike Colter wearing a leather jacket and Aasif Mandvi wearing a brown jacket

The stars of Evil investigate another unnerving case.

Photo: Jeff Neumann/CBS ©2019 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved

If a demon makes you commit murder, are you guilty? And if you confess during exorcism, should Kristen call the cops? Ethical head-scratchers abound in this episode, which features a terrific appearance by Tony winner Annaleigh Ashford (B Positive, Masters of Sex, Kinky Boots) as tortured housewife Bridget/murderous demon Howard. When Kristen asks Bridget/Howard how she killed the missing children, the answer reveals more than she bargained for.

The Goblin Birth (S1, E8)

Mike Colter taking a phone call next to a small bonfire

David listens intently to a caller.

Photo: Elizabeth Fisher/CBS ©2019 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved

Ever since Children of the Corn, we have been advocating for trigger warnings on cornfields, so this one really freaked us out. David’s estranged father has been painting demonic sigils and living in a throuple at a commune upstate. Everyone there drinks ’shroom sangria, so it’s unclear whether what Kristen sees is real. We hope not, because the only thing scarier than a cornfield is the bloody birth of a goblin baby in the middle of a cornfield.

The Murderous Nurse (S1, E11)

Mike Colter in a hospital bed covered in a yellow blanket with Kristen Connolly, Kristen Bouchard, and Aasif Mandvi standing next to his bedside

David’s hospital stay turns out to be more perilous than his original injury.

Photo: Gail Schulman/CBS ©2019 CBS Broadcasting, Inc. All Rights Reserved

David is in the hospital recovering from a near-fatal stabbing, when a fellow African American patient warns him that the nurse with the squeaky shoes is murdering Black patients and collecting their ID bracelets as trophies. Only David’s incredible strength of will and Kristen’s quick thinking can save him.

The Severed Finger (S2, E1)

Maddy Crocco looking into a bathroom mirror holding her canine tooth and a bloody rag

Tooth trouble: Lexis inspects her teeth in the bathroom mirror while clutching a bloody rag.

Photo: Elizabeth Fisher/CBS 2021Paramount+ Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Puberty is hard for everyone, but Kristen’s daughter Lexis—conceived with the help of the demonic RCM Fertility clinic—has grown fangs. In the middle of routine surgery to remove them, the supposedly unconscious Lexis chomps down, severing her doctor’s finger and making us spill whatever was left of our drink.

The Teka Teka Girl (S2, E4)

Aasif Mandvi standing in a wooden elevator shaft looking petrified

Ben is struck with terror during an elevator ride (literally) from hell.

Photo: Elizabeth Fisher/CBS 2021Paramount+ Inc. All Rights Reserved.

After a local teen disappears, the team discovers “The Elevator Game,” an urban legend that sends players on an elevator ride to hell. Ben gives it a go and gets trapped alone in the underworld. But the scariest part is when Kristen is wedged between floors and hears “teka teka,” the sound of a legless ghost dragging herself across the hall.

The Evil Doll Altar (S2, E6)

Christine Lahti in a bedroom looking at a doll on an altar between two candles while Maddy Crocco looks on in the background

Sheryl admires the creepy altar she's constructed while Lexis looks on in dismay.

Photo: Elizabeth Fisher/CBS 2021Paramount+ Inc. All Rights Reserved.

From her secret affair with her daughter’s nemesis Leland to her inappropriate gifts of VR goggles, Grandma Sheryl (Christine Lahti) has to be the world’s worst free babysitter. Sheryl hits a new low when she shows granddaughter Lexis a candlelit altar where she prays to a cracked porcelain doll named Eddie who makes Chuckie look cuddly. Lexis is terrified and so are we.

The World’s Worst Date (S2, E10)

Tim Matheson and Christine Lahti laying on the floor next to a black sofa holding hands with IVs attached to their legs

Oh, what a night: Edward and Sheryl after one too many strange cocktails

Photo: Elizabeth Fisher/CBS 2021Paramount+ Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Grandma Sheryl drinks too many cocktails with Leland’s bff Edward (Tim Matheson), who delivers the scariest line of dialogue in the whole show: “If you tried to stand right now, could you?” She can’t. Soon, Edward and Leland are strapping her down and giving her an IV of a mysterious brown liquid. What is it? We don’t even know! In the morning, Sheryl acts like nothing happened.

The World’s Worst Dinner Party (S2, E13)

Christine Lahti wearing a party hat and holding a platter of greens and human flesh while Michael Emerson stands beside her with some in his hand

Stomach turner: Leland peels a piece of human flesh off a platter held by Sheryl.

Photo: Elizabeth Fisher/CBS 2021Paramount+ Inc. All Rights Reserved.

In the Season Two finale, the team assesses a vegetarian medical student seized by the sudden desire to eat human flesh. The trio tries to counsel poor Mitch (Taylor Trensch) through his cravings, but Leland foils them and brings Mitch home to a Hannibal Lecter–style dinner. “Kumbaya” plays as Leland carves a demonic sigil off the scalp of a corpse and presents it to Mitch as an amuse-bouche.

The Haunted Toilet (S3, E2)

Christine Lahti wearing a full white fur coat and looking backwards over her shoulder

Sheryl glances warily over her shoulder.

Photo Credit: Elizabeth Fisher/Paramount+

Kristen’s husband Andy discovered a shrunken head in a jar (courtesy of Grandma Sheryl, of course) lurking beneath their bed. He flushed the head down the toilet in the previous episode, but as every New Yorker knows, old plumbing can be a nightmare. The toilet terrifies his littlest daughter—and us—by overflowing with blood.

The Radio Show from Hell (S3, E4)

Mike Colter in a green hoodie and beanie and a brown jacket looking surprised

David finds himself on a lonesome stretch of highway at night.

Photo Credit: Elizabeth Fisher/Paramount+

A trucker’s wife believes he is possessed by a haunted stretch of I-95, so our heroes drive out to investigate. As soon as they hit exit 13a, their road trip playlist is preempted by screams. A flying object with two red eyes appears in the darkness. The radio tunes itself to 666 AM, and a voice drawls, “It’s a short slide to hell, Ben.”

The Blood-Sucking Nightmare (S3, E6)

Andrea Martin dressed as a nun standing next to a creepy black monster with its hand on her throat

Sister Andrea confronts Mosquito Demon (Marti Matulis).

Photo Credit: Elizabeth Fisher/Paramount+

We love feisty Sister Andrea, played by the talented Andrea Martin of SCTV fame. When she hears a strange gurgling inside David’s room, the good sister discovers a repulsive winged creature crouched over him, sucking blood through a proboscis. Grabbing a Bible, she fights it off, but David only scolds her for disturbing his sleep.

“What are you doing?” she asks.

We’re wondering the same thing.

Catch up on all episodes of Evilstreaming on Paramount+.

SUBSCRIBE NOW: Enjoy 4 Digital Plus 2 Print/Digital Issues Of Watch Per Year — For Free!