In an unusual turn of events for Steam reviews, the roguelike cooking game “Omelet You Cook” has encountered its first negative feedback. Up until now, the game, developed by SchuBox Games, had maintained a flawless record with over 500 positive reviews. The community’s positive reception made it one of a select few games to reach such a milestone. However, everything changed when a solitary negative review appeared.
A Surprising Twist
The unexpected review came to light when developer Dan Schumacher shared his disappointment. The reviewer’s comment was not even truly critical of the game. Instead, they wrote, “Game is amazing. I just like to be different,” having played for only 0.8 hours. This particular review has stirred a passionate response from the community, which has rallied behind the game, adding nearly 40 positive reviews in its defense. At the same time, some comments have been harsher than the original negative remark.
Schumacher expressed his frustration, noting that while the streak of perfect reviews was not expected to last forever, it was painful to have it broken by someone who still praised the game. “Emotionally I think I’d feel better if it was someone complaining about bugs, or design choices, or just feeling the game isn’t for them,” he stated.
The Impact of Reviews
While a single negative review might not significantly impact SchuBox Games, the loss of a perfect score does matter. Very few games on Steam manage to maintain entirely positive reviews, and this achievement had garnered attention for “Omelet You Cook.” Schumacher acknowledged that the game’s perfect rating piqued curiosity, leading players to explore reviews or try the demo themselves. This unique status even drew new members to their Discord community.
Schumacher noted that despite the change, the difference between a 99% and 100% rating might not deter players. In fact, some users prefer to filter reviews by their negativity to understand potential issues, and this negative review still casts a favorable light on the game.
Looking Ahead
Engagement on Steam is crucial for small developers. Positive reviews can dramatically increase a game’s visibility, especially when competing in a crowded marketplace. SchuBox Games feels fortunate to have reached 507 positive reviews before encountering their first negative one. The team attributes this success to their hard work, having released 15 content updates over five months. Schumacher expressed gratitude towards the reviewers, acknowledging that each positive review helps “Omelet You Cook” reach a broader audience and continue thriving.